Cliff House Project

Introduction ] Photos ] Photos 2 ] Timeline ] stories ] Virtual Tour ] Postcards ] trade cards ] Stereoviews ] Tintypes ] Slides ] Film ] Interiors ] Illustrations ] Multimedia ] Model ] Exonumia ] Misc ] Documents ] Books ] Environs ] Studio ] Transportation ] Blueprints ] Maps ] Other Cliff Houses ] [ Detractors ] Then-Now ] research ] Prints ] FAQ ] Wish ] Links ] Thanks ]

 

Detractors

 

The Victorian Cliff House was not without controversy in its time.  It had its share of detractors...

"Like everything else fashioned by the mind and taste of the late Mr. Sutro, it was a thing of complicated and amazing ugliness."
--The Argonaut, September 14, 1907. Vol. LXI, No. 1590.

And a letter writer in the same issue...

"Of the thousands who, on last Sunday morning, opened their paper and read 'Famous Cliff House Is Totally Destroyed by Fire,' were there, do you think, a score who did not ejaculate 'Thank Heaven!'?

"It's tawdry architecture, its ungainly proportions, its dirty corridors and opaque windows, its wretched cuisine, its musical instruments of torture, its approaches lined with either cheap or deserted booths---all have made hideous a spot which Nature meant to be beautiful."


billboards near entrance

"Showing how the beauty of the most picturesque and romantic spot on the Pacific Coast has been heightened by the erection of a wooden bird cage and a half-gross assortment of triangles."

Part of a whole page of Victorian architecture similarly ridiculed. ("Chaos Avenue: An Architect's Nightmare") From "The Wave", March 20, 1897, pg. 6.

 


San Francisco Call - 9 Sept 1907

 

REPORT ON A PLAN FOR SAN FRANCISCO, BY DANIEL H. BURNHAM
September 1904

"The Cliff House should be condemned, removed and a concourse providing some slight shelter substituted, thus opening to the view the sweep of the headlands to the north and the ocean from the Cliff House road."


Full text:  DanielBurnham.pdf

Created from the original scanned document by Jacques Servin, posted here with his permission
http://www.netzaesthetik.de/Servin/


 

You are visitor number: